^ Back to Top
lime Screen Review: The Fifth Estate

Lime Review - Screen

The Fifth Estate






words by

Cassam Looch

Reporter: Cassam Looch

Another film about wikileaks, but this one isn’t a documentary. ‘We steal secrets:


The Story of Wikileaks’ was the Alex Gibney take from earlier this year, but this time we get a dramatised version with Benedict Cumberbatch assuming the role of Julian Assange.

 
 
 
It’s an interesting impersonation by one of the most in-demand actors, and although the voice and mannerisms seem to be all there, it still just looks like TV’s Sherlock in a grey wig. The real problem with the film is that it doesn’t know what it wants to be, and it also skirts over the more controversial aspects of the Assange story.
 
 
 
There are obvious nods to ‘The Social Network’, and in some of its more focussed moments, the film is positively compelling. Unfortunately we also get scenes where we are “taken out of the moment” with unnecessary visualisations of online chatter. The rushed finish, which Gibney handled with aplomb, is given a dismissive comedic slant, something which doesn’t do anybody any favours.
 
 
 
A story which may well offer up a great dramatic film, but it needs to be resolved in real-life before it can hit the screens. See ‘Captain Phillips’ for evidence of that.
 
 
 
Starring: Benedict Cumberbatch, Daniel Brühl and Peter Capaldi
 
 
 
Release Date: October 11th
Some other Screen reviews ...
Shadow Dancer Screen review
Shadow Dancer
WORDS: Cassam Looch
Films to watch out for Screen review
Films to watch out for
WORDS: Cassam Looch
Black Nativity Screen review
Black Nativity
WORDS: Cassam Looch
... and some other reviews by Cassam Looch
The Imposter    Screen review
The Imposter
WORDS: Cassam Looch
Paranorman 3D Screen review
Paranorman 3D
WORDS: Cassam Looch
Searching For Sugar Man Screen review
Searching For Sugar Man
WORDS: Cassam Looch